+ 1-888-787-5890  
   + 1-302-351-4405  
 
 
 
 

Essay/Term paper: Criticism of "the sick rose"

Essay, term paper, research paper:  Book Reports

Free essays available online are good but they will not follow the guidelines of your particular writing assignment. If you need a custom term paper on Book Reports: Criticism Of "The Sick Rose", you can hire a professional writer here to write you a high quality authentic essay. While free essays can be traced by Turnitin (plagiarism detection program), our custom written essays will pass any plagiarism test. Our writing service will save you time and grade.



Criticism of "The Sick Rose"


By analyzing more information from different authors, I was able to draw
a greater amount contrast from the authors. I had a better feel for what they
were trying to convey when they wrote their critical essays in their books.
Whatever the case, it was easier to judge "The Sick Rose" by having more sources
to reflect upon.

Michael Riffaterre centers his analysis of "The Sick Rose" in "The Self-
sufficient Text" by "using internal evidence only [to analyze the poem] and to
determine to what extent the literary text is self-sufficient. It seems to
[Riffaterre] that a proper reading entails no more than a knowledge of the
language" (39). Riffaterre identifies psychological, philosophical, and genetic
interpretations (connected to "mythological tradition") as "aiming outwards."
These approaches find the meaning of the text in the relationship of its images
to other texts" (40). Riffaterre argues for a more internal reading of the poems.
Riffaterre emphasizes the importance of the relationships between words as
opposed to their "corresponding realities" (40). For example, he states that the
"flower or the fruit is a variant of the worm's dwelling constructed through
destruction. Thus, as a word, worm is meaningful only in the context of flower,
and flower only in the context of worm" (41). After Riffaterre's reading and in
terpretation of the poem, he concludes that "The Sick Rose" is composed of
"polarized polarities" (44) which convey the central object of the poem, the
actual phrase, "the sick rose" (44). He asserts that "because the text provides
all the elements necessary to our identifying these verbal artifacts, we do not
have to resort to traditions or symbols found outside the text" (44). Thus, "The
Sick Rose" is a self-sufficient text.

Hazard Adams takes a different approach to reading "The Sick Rose" than
most critics by cautioning the reader that often one "overlook[s] the fact that
a literary image primarily imitates its previous usages and secondarily what it
denotes in the outer world or in the realm of ideas" (13). Adams begins his
analysis with examining the rose, and by reminding the reader that in a
"literary world where the rose is seen archetypally, all things have human form"
(14). Thus he allows for the rose to be able to become part of the speaker. He
carries his idea one step further by suggesting that the speaker always
"address[es] some aspect of himself" when speaking to an object. Adams also
claims this same identification with the worm as with the rose. He further warns
against reading the poem as a simple allegory of sexual seduction; Blake
considered that "allegory can contain 'some vision'"(15). Thus, it seems that
there is more to the poem than just a surface level reading. Adams concludes by
stating that when reading Blake's poems, the reader should consider "minute
particulars," "perspective, to related images in Blake's other works, and to
symbolic conventions in literature" (15-16).

John Hollowly also approaches an analysis of "The Sick Rose by warning
the reader against unnecessarily complicating the poems by not beginning with
the simple language of the text and its images. He claims that "the language of
the poem does its work by being somehow transparent; and the subject gains
pregnancy of meaning . . . because of how it stands in a revelatory position . .
. seen across the whole spectrum of our existence" (24). He explains that "The
Sick Rose" is a popular poem because of the simple tension between the beautiful
rose and the "secret, pallid . . . repulsive" worm (25). Holloway also argues
that "The Sick Rose" is a retort to poems by Bunyan and Watts. Blake seems to
identify religion as an "enemy to life" (if the worm is read to symbolize
religion and the rose as life), unlike the poems of Bunyan and Watts that
advocate "virtue not pleasure" (44).

In 1987, Elizabeth Langland "[wed] feminist and formal-thematic
methodologies to analyze Blake's 'The Sick Rose'" (225) in "Blake's Feminist
Revision of Literary Tradition in 'The Sick Rose'." In her consideration of the
"critical tradition" (228) as a tool of study, Langland reviews the
interpretations of other critics such as Hirsch and Bloom. Based on the feminine
critique method, Langland suggests a reading in the critical tradition may
reveal "the suspicion and possible hostility . . . toward a certain kind of
woman" (231). Her investigation then focuses on the speakers in the poem, and
from a feminist perspective, she claims that the poem is read "in the context of
a patriarchal speaker" (231). This reveals the way in which expectations affect
a reading and assumptions about the text. Thirdly, Langland examines "the ways
language, syntax, . . . and illuminations work to establish new readings" (228).
Langland also includes discussions on the revisions of the poems and how they
affect the poem
as well as the reader's response/interpretation generally.

In general "The Sick Rose" criticisms from these four authors are
favorable and just for each of their own view points. "The Sick Rose"
represents each and every one of their ideas in their own way. William Blake
surely has put forth an excellent piece of poetry for all ages and generations
to enjoy.

Works Cited

Adams, Hazard. William Blake. Seattle: U of Washington P, 1963.

Riffaterre, Michael. "The Self-sufficient text." Diacritics 3.3 (1973): 39-45.

Holloway, John. Blake: The Lyric Poetry. London: Arnold, 1968.

Langland, Elizabeth. "Blake's Feminist Revision of Literary Tradition in 'The
Sick Rose'." In Critical Paths. Ed. Dan Miller, Mark Bracher, and Donald Ault.
Durham: Duke UP, 1987. 225-43.

 

Other sample model essays:

The Crucible: Although Abigail and The Girls Initiate The Tragedy, Responsibility Lies With the Whole Salem Community Although Abigail and the girls initiate the tragedy, responsibility lies w...
Cry The Beloved Country: Book Review Lee Brown Tina Winings Acc. Lit. & Comp. Sept. 25, 1997 "Cry, the beloved country, for the unborn child that is the ...
Book Reports / Cyrano De Bergerac
Cyrano De Bergerac Every generation has its own heroes that display, what they believe to be, ideal characteristics. While each is different in their own way, many of these role models sha...
The Scarlet Letter: Darkness Illuminated Since the conception of humanity, man has been fascinated with that presence which illuminates, yet cannot be touched. Mankind has brought it into ...
Darkness; Beacon of Chaos in Macbeth Darkness in our society is indicative of evil. For instance, a black cat, a dark night, and a dark place are all symbolic of diablerie. Authors u...
David Williamson's "The Club" and "The Removalists" Part A In his play The Club, David Williamson presents numerous Australian attitudes of the 1970s. However, many of these attitu...
The Pardoner's Tale: Themes of Death and Greed In the Pardoner's Tale death first takes shape as a thief stealing a man's life. This thief is first believed to be a man, which the trio is g...
Death of a Salesman: Willy's Life Is An Illusion Charley says something in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman that sums up Willy's whole life. He asks him, "When the hell are you going to ...
Death of a Salesman / Death Of A Salesman: Symbols
Death of a Salesman: Symbols Many symbols are incorporated into the play "Death of a Sales man" and they in turn relate to both character and theme. The hose, tape recorder and the seeds are ...
Book Reports / Deliverance
Deliverance A true survivor can only depend on himself. The novel Deliverance is a story about four characters each with different views on surviving. Every man in the world can relate to o...
Experience with Dream Essay - Reliable and great customer service. Quality of work - High quality of work.
Browns Mills, New Jersey, United States
Dream Essay - Very reliable and great customer service. Encourage other to try their service. Writer 91463 - Provided a well written Annotated Bibliography with great deal of detail per the rubric.
Browns Mills, New Jersey, United States
it is always perfect
Frederick, Maryland, United States
The experience with Dream Essay is stress free. Service is excellent and forms various forms of communication all help with customer service. Dream Essay is customer oriented. Writer 17663 is absolutely excellent. This writer provides the highest quality of work possible.
Browns Mills, New Jersey, United States
Only competent & proven writers
Original writing — no plagiarism
Our papers are never resold or reused, period
Satisfaction guarantee — free unlimited revisions
Client-friendly money back guarantee
Total confidentiality & privacy
Guaranteed deadlines
Live Chat & 24/7 customer support
All academic and professional subjects
All difficulty levels
12pt Times New Roman font, double spaced, 1 inch margins
The fastest turnaround in the industry
Fully documented research — free bibliography guaranteed
Fax (additional info): 866-332-0244
Fax (additional info): 866-308-7123
Live Chat Support
Need order related assistance?—Click here to submit a inquiry
© Dreamessays.com. All Rights Reserved.
Dreamessays.com is the property of MEDIATECH LTD